An ideal smart ceiling fan should seamlessly integrate into your home’s ecosystem, providing comfort without adding complexity. In this guide, I’ll help you navigate through various options that are designed for ease of use, ensuring that they contribute positively to your daily routines rather than becoming a source of frustration.
What to expect: This article will focus on brand new fans with wireless smart technology built right into them. If you are interested in retrofitting your existing ceiling fan with smart technology, take a look at this article instead.
I have selected smart ceiling fans that fit a wide range of budgets with the main focus on usability and smart home integration. After listing my top picks, I’ll guide you through important considerations like the necessity of wall controls for seamless operation, the right fan size for your room, and the different ceiling fan motor types.
Smart Ceiling Fan ‘Quick Pick’
I found that the Minka-Aire smart ceiling fans are an excellent choice for most people. They are well-built fans at a reasonable price and come in a variety of sizes and styles. They come with light-weight, efficient DC motors. They use the WiFi based Smart By Bond technology which insures a reliable connection and integration with most of the major smart home platforms. And, to make smart control as painless as possible, they come with a hard-wired wall control (a “must-have” IMO).
Why Trust Me?
My name is Eric Blank and I’ve been running thesmartcave.com since 2016. While it’s true that this site earns through affiliate links, my priority has always been to offer honest advice, not just to chase commissions. My recommendations are based on extensive research and personal experience with smart ceiling fans.
I currently have both a Modern Forms fan (review) and a Smafan (review) installed in my home. I also have the Bond Bridge (review) which gives me access to all the same features as the Smart By Bond technology included with the Minka-Aire smart fans.
How I Chose the Best Smart Ceiling Fans
There are only a handful of companies that make smart ceiling fans. However, each company makes a wide variety of models in different sizes and styles. Therefore, there are literally hundreds of smart ceiling fan models available. For that reason, it’s basically impossible to choose one smart ceiling fan that is the BEST.
That said, all of the smart fans made by a given company share the majority of their features. So, rather than focusing on specific models for this review, I will focus on reviewing the different companies, with a special focus on the quality and usability of their smart home integration.
Best Smart Ceiling Fans in 2024
Minka-Aire Smart Ceiling Fans
Connectivity: WiFi
Smart Home Integration: Integrations via Smart By Bond - Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Home Assistant, SmartThings, Control4, ELAN, Crestron, Hubitat
App Features: Uses Bond Home app
Control Options: Remote with cradle, wall control included, voice control, app control
Speed Settings: 6 speed DC motor, reversible
Lighting: Integrated dimmable LED module, 3000k, CRI:94, 1544 lumens
Warranty: 1 year for fan, lifetime for motor
The Minka-Aire smart ceiling fan is a modern, WiFi-connected ceiling fan, suitable for a variety of smart home setups. Its integration capabilities with Smart By Bond, including compatibility with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Home Assistant, SmartThings, Control4, ELAN, Crestron, and Hubitat, make it a versatile option for both advanced and novice users. The inclusion of an integrated dimmable LED module enhances its appeal.
What I Like
- All Users: The Minka-Aire fan's reliability and performance are standout features. Its energy efficiency, with a 6-speed DC motor and reversible functionality, appeals to users conscious about energy consumption.
- Advanced Users: The fan's extensive smart home integration via Smart By Bond, and the ease of voice control, are significant advantages. The ability to control various settings through the Bond Home app is another plus.
- Novice Users: The fan is user-friendly, with a remote control and wall control included. Its essential features like dimmable LED lighting are straightforward and easy to use, making it an excellent choice for those new to smart home technology.
What I Don’t Like
- All Users: The Minka-Aire fan could benefit from stronger security features, which is a common concern among smart home devices.
- Advanced Users: While the product offers extensive integrations, there might be limitations in technical support for complex setups or troubleshooting.
- Novice Users: The scalability of the fan might be limited for those looking to expand their smart home system beyond basic functionalities.
Verdict
The Minka-Aire smart ceiling fan is a strong contender in the smart home market, offering a balance of features suitable for both advanced and novice users. Its extensive compatibility with major smart home platforms and its user-friendly controls make it a versatile and convenient choice. However, users should be aware of potential limitations in security and technical support. Overall, its advantages in connectivity and ease of use provide good value for its price.
- Wide range of smart home integrations
- Energy-efficient with a 6-speed reversible DC motor
- Includes both remote and wall control
- Integrated dimmable LED lighting
- Potential security concerns common to smart devices
- Limited technical support for complex setups
- Scalability might be limited for expansive smart home systems
Modern Forms Smart Ceiling Fan
Connectivity: WiFi
Smart Home Integration: Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Home Assistant, ecobee, SmartThings, Control4, josh.ai, Crestron
App Features: Uses Modern Forms app for controlling fan speed, light brightness, breeze mode, fan direction, creating groups, and scheduling
Control Options: Bluetooth remote control with wall cradle, optional hardwired Bluetooth wall control, voice control, app control
Speed Settings: DC motor, 6 speeds, reversible
Lighting: Built-in dimmable LED 3000K (options for 2700k or 3500k), 1100 lumens
Warranty: 5 years indoor, 2 years outdoor finish, 1 year outdoor, lifetime for motor and stainless steel finishes
The Modern Forms smart ceiling fan stands out in the smart home market with its extensive compatibility across many popular smart home platforms. It offers features like voice control, app-based management, and a sleek, modern design, appealing to both advanced and novice users. Its integrations with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Home Assistant, ecobee, SmartThings, Control4, and others, make it a versatile choice for various smart home environments.
What I Like
All Users: The Modern Forms fan's broad smart home integration and the ability to control fan speed, light brightness, and other settings via the Modern Forms app cater to all users. Its built-in dimmable LED with different color temperature options is a plus.
Advanced Users: They will appreciate the fan's native integrations with multiple platforms and the option for a hardwired Bluetooth wall control. Its Bluetooth remote control with wall cradle offers additional convenience.
Novice Users: The fan's ease of use through app and voice control is ideal for those new to smart home technology. Its aesthetic appeal and basic features like reversible fan speed settings are also notable.
What I Don’t Like
All Users: The need to purchase a hardwired wall control separately can be a downside for users who prefer physical control options.
Advanced Users: While the fan offers robust integration options, the lack of advanced technical support or expanded scalability might be a drawback.
Novice Users: The fan's broad range of features, while beneficial, might overwhelm those new to smart home technology, and the additional cost for the hardwired wall control could be seen as a negative.
Verdict
The Modern Forms smart ceiling fan is a strong contender in the smart home market. Its extensive compatibility and feature set make it an excellent choice for advanced users who can leverage its smart integrations and customization options. Novice users will also find it appealing for its ease of use and essential smart features, though the additional cost for a physical wall control should be considered. Overall, it offers a good balance between advanced functionality and user-friendly operation.
- Extensive smart home integration (Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, etc.)
- App control for fan speed, light brightness, and more
- Sleek, modern design
- Built-in dimmable LED with different color temperature options
- Bluetooth remote control with wall cradle
- Hardwired wall control sold separately
- Might be overwhelming for novice users
- Lacks advanced technical support options
SMAFAN Smart Ceiling Fan
Connectivity: WiFi
Smart Home Integration: Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri Shortcuts, Home Assistant, Tuya/Smart Life
App Features: Uses Carro Home App (Tuya/Smart Life compatible). Control fan speed, light brightness and temperature, nature mode, fan direction. Create groups and schedules.
Control Options: Remote with wall cradle, voice control, app control
Speed Settings: DC motor, 10 speeds, reversible
Lighting: Built-in dimmable LED light, 2700k, 3000k, 3500k, 846 lumens
Warranty: 3 years for fan and motor, 5 years for light kit
The Smafan smart ceiling fan is a technologically advanced and affordable option in the smart ceiling fan market. Key features include WiFi connectivity, compatibility with a range of smart home platforms like Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri Shortcuts, and Home Assistant, and a versatile Carro Home App for control. It stands out for its adjustable light temperature and a notably lower price point, making it an attractive choice for both novice and advanced users.
What I Like
All Users: The Smafan fan offers robust smart home integration and adjustable LED lighting, catering to a wide range of preferences. Its WiFi connectivity ensures easy remote access.
Advanced Users: The fan's compatibility with various smart platforms, including Tuya/Smart Life, and the ability to use Tuya local with Home Assistant for local control, is a significant plus. Its 10-speed reversible DC motor offers granular control over airflow.
Novice Users: The fan's ease of use, especially with the Carro Home App, is commendable. Its simple remote control and voice control options are user-friendly, making it accessible for those new to smart home technology.
What I Don't Like
All Users: The separation of white and yellow light controls might be cumbersome for some users.
Advanced Users: Lack of an option for a hard-wired wall control could be a limitation for those seeking a more integrated, permanent installation.
Novice Users: While it offers great basic functionality, the fan might not be as scalable or versatile in a complex smart home setup compared to some more expensive alternatives.
Verdict
The Smafan smart ceiling fan is a solid choice for both novice and advanced users. Its competitive pricing, coupled with a range of desirable features like smart home integration and adjustable lighting, makes it a valuable addition to most homes. While it may lack some advanced control options, its overall functionality and ease of use present a great balance of performance and convenience.
- Broad smart home platform compatibility
- Adjustable LED light temperature
- 10-speed reversible DC motor
- User-friendly Carro Home App
- Competitive pricing
- Separate controls for white and yellow light
- No hard-wired wall control option
- Limited scalability in complex setups
Big Ass Fans es6 Smart Ceiling Fan
Connectivity: WiFi
Smart Home Integration: Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Home Assistant, ecobee
App Features: Uses Big Ass Fans app for grouping with other Haiku products, controlling fan speed, light brightness and color, Whoosh Mode, and scheduling
Control Options: Optional Wired Wall Control, infrared motion sensor, voice activation, mobile app, optional 0-10v module
Speed Settings: EC motor, 7 speeds, not reversible
Lighting: Optional chromatic uplight with RGB color soft or bright white (up to 1845 lumens), dimmable night light, optional LED downlight with 16 dimmable settings, 2700k and 4000k, 1770 lumens
Warranty: 3 years
The Big Ass Fans es6 is a feature-rich smart ceiling fan that stands out in the smart home market. It integrates seamlessly with popular platforms like Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Home Assistant, offering a high degree of compatibility for both novice and advanced users. Its unique features, such as colored uplight and adjustable temperature downlight, along with the SenseMe technology incorporating temperature, humidity, and motion sensors, make it a top-tier choice for smart home enthusiasts.
What I Like
All Users: The es6 offers robust connectivity with WiFi and excellent smart home integration, making it a great fit for any smart home setup.
Advanced Users: The fan's compatibility with various smart home platforms and the use of the Big Ass Fans app for advanced controls (like Whoosh Mode) cater to those who prefer a more intricate setup. The inclusion of an optional 0-10v module and SenseMe technology are bonuses.
Novice Users: Ease of use is a big plus here. The option for voice activation and an intuitive mobile app makes it accessible for beginners. The optional wired wall control and infrared motion sensor add to its user-friendly nature.
What I Don’t Like
All Users: The high price point can be a significant barrier. Security concerns aren't highlighted, but the price might be a deterrent for some.
Advanced Users: The absence of Apple HomeKit integration could be a downside for those heavily invested in the Apple ecosystem.
Novice Users: The es6 might be too complex and expensive for users who just need a basic smart fan. Its range of advanced features could be overwhelming for someone seeking simplicity.
Verdict
The Big Ass Fans es6 is an excellent choice for users who want a high-end, feature-rich smart ceiling fan and are willing to invest in it. It's particularly suited for advanced users who will appreciate its extensive integration and advanced features. Novice users might find it too complex and expensive, so it's less recommended for those seeking basic functionality and budget-friendliness.
- Extensive smart home integration
- Advanced features like SenseMe technology and colored uplights
- User-friendly with voice activation and app control
- High cost
- No Apple HomeKit integration
- Potentially overwhelming for novice users
Hunter Smart Ceiling Fans
Connectivity: WiFi
Smart Home Integration: Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, Google Assistant
App Features: Uses SIMPLEconnect app for controlling fan speed, light brightness, fan direction
Control Options: Remote control, voice control, app control
Speed Settings: 4 speed AC motor, reversible
Lighting: 2 replaceable dimmable LED bulbs
Warranty: 1 year for fan, lifetime for motor
The Hunter smart ceiling fan stands out in the realm of smart ceiling fans with its compatibility with major smart home platforms like Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, and Google Assistant. Its SIMPLEconnect app allows users to control fan speed and light brightness, with the added convenience of reversible fan direction. This fan is particularly appealing to users who are invested in the Apple ecosystem, due to its native support for Apple HomeKit.
What I Like:
All Users: The Hunter fan's integration with major smart home platforms and the ability to control basic features via the SIMPLEconnect app is a big plus. Its compatibility with Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, and Google Assistant makes it versatile for various smart home setups.
Advanced Users: The native support for Apple HomeKit is a standout feature, providing seamless integration for users in the Apple ecosystem. Additionally, the fan's reversible feature and app-controlled adjustments cater well to users seeking more control over their smart home devices.
Novice Users: The replaceable LED bulbs are a user-friendly feature, making maintenance simpler for those less experienced with smart home technology. The remote control also offers a straightforward way for novice users to operate the fan without delving into the complexities of smart home integration.
What I Don’t Like:
All Users: A significant concern is the history of poor connectivity with the SIMPLEconnect app, which could affect reliability. However, it's noteworthy that the fan performs better with Apple HomeKit integration.
Advanced Users: The lack of integration with Home Assistant, unless through Apple HomeKit, might limit the fan's appeal to users with a more diverse or complex smart home system.
Novice Users: The fan's connectivity issues might be daunting for less tech-savvy users who expect a plug-and-play experience.
Verdict: The Hunter smart ceiling fan is a solid choice for users deeply invested in the Apple ecosystem, thanks to its native HomeKit support. Its straightforward remote control makes it accessible to novice users. However, its connectivity issues and limited integration outside the Apple framework might deter advanced users with more diverse smart home setups.
- Compatible with major smart home platforms (Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, Google Assistant).
- Replaceable LED bulbs for easy maintenance.
- Remote control for simple operation.
- History of connectivity issues with SIMPLEconnect app.
- Limited integration with Home Assistant without Apple HomeKit.
- May not cater to advanced users with non-Apple smart home systems.
Big Ass Fans Haiku L Smart Ceiling Fan
Connectivity: WiFi
Smart Home Integration: Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, Home Assistant
App Features: Uses Big Ass Fans app for grouping with other Haiku products, controlling fan speed, light brightness, Whoosh Mode, and scheduling
Control Options: Remote control with wall mount, optional wall control, voice control, app control
Speed Settings: EC motor, 7 speeds, not reversible, max speed: 5604cfm, 181 rpm, 18.9W
Lighting: 16 light levels, 2700K, 988 lumens
Warranty: 3 years on fan, 5 years on motor controller and light, lifetime on motor
The Big Ass Fans Haiku L smart ceiling fan is a high-end option for those seeking a blend of style, efficiency, and smart home integration. It stands out with its efficient EC motor and compatibility with major smart home platforms like Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Home Assistant. Its unique feature includes a 16-level light setting and the ability to group with other Haiku products for a synchronized experience. This fan, while ideal for advanced users due to its efficiency and smart features, is also suitable for novices who appreciate simplicity and ease of use.
What I Like
All Users: The Haiku L's efficient EC motor and 16 light levels offer a blend of energy efficiency and customizable lighting, appealing to all users. Its WiFi connectivity ensures easy integration into smart home setups.
Advanced Users: The compatibility with major platforms like Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, along with the ability to group with other Haiku products, makes this fan a great choice for those with existing smart home ecosystems. The non-reversible 7-speed settings provide varied airflow options.
Novice Users: The Big Ass Fans app is straightforward, allowing easy control over fan speed, light brightness, and Whoosh Mode. The remote control with a wall mount offers a tangible, user-friendly option for those less comfortable with app-based controls.
What I Don’t Like
All Users: The primary drawback is the cost, as it's one of the more expensive options on the market, which might not appeal to budget-conscious buyers.
Advanced Users: The lack of Big Ass Fan's SenseMe technology, available in higher-end models, might be a downside for those seeking more advanced environmental sensing capabilities.
Novice Users: The fan's high cost and complexity might be intimidating for novice users who are looking for a simple, entry-level smart fan.
Verdict
The Big Ass Fans Haiku L is a premium choice for those who value efficiency, style, and smart integration. Its high price point is justified by its performance and features, making it a suitable investment for advanced users deeply invested in smart home technology. Novice users who are willing to spend more for a top-quality product will also find it user-friendly, but those on a tight budget might consider more affordable options.
- Efficient EC motor with 7 speeds.
- Wide compatibility with major smart home platforms.
- User-friendly app with grouping features.
- 16 light levels for customizable lighting.
- Includes remote control with a wall mount.
- High price point.
- Absence of advanced SenseMe technology found in other Big Ass Fans models.
Buying Guide: What makes an ideal smart ceiling fan?
What follows in this buying guide are a few considerations that I have found to be important while researching and using smart ceiling fans. Hopefully, this information is actually helpful.
Wall Controls are Ideal
I have found that when using smart home devices that are traditionally operated by a wall switch (such as lights or ceiling fans), it is ideal to have a functional hard-wired wall switch if possible.
- If you already have a functioning on/off wall switch for your ceiling fan, then that switch will be a nuisance if your new smart fan does not come with a wall control.
- You won’t be able to control the fan function with the switch (turning the switch on, won’t turn on the fan).
- If you turn the switch off, it will cut all power to the fan which will render any smart functionality useless.
- It helps to have a means of control that is always in the same location. Many of the smart fans come with remotes, which seems adequate. But in reality, a remote is just another device you need to keep track of. To combat that issue, most smart ceiling fans with remotes also come with a cradle that holds the remote which can be mounted to the wall. That works fine, but at that point you might as well just have a wall control.
- You want a means of control that works even if the internet is down. A wall control will have a direct connection to the ceiling fan (either via wires or wireless) regardless of whether your home’s WiFi is working. In this sense, a remote will provide similar function.
Ceiling Fan Size Guide
In general, the ideal size of a ceiling fan will vary depending on the size of the room. The table below gives you a guide for ceiling fan size based on different room sizes.
Room Size (sq ft) | Fan Size 8ft ceiling (inches) | Fan Size >10′ ceiling (inches) |
Up to 75 | 29-36 | 36-42 |
76-144 | 36-42 | 42-48 |
145-225 | 44-50 | 50-54 |
226-300 | 50-54 | 54-60 |
301-400 | 50-60 | 56-60 |
401-500 | 60-72 or two 44-50 | 60-72 or two smaller fans |
- Room Size: The size of the fan should correspond to the size of the room. A larger room requires more air movement, so a larger fan makes sense. Additionally, the fan’s size should complement the room’s aesthetics. A fan that is too large can overpower a room, while a too-small fan may look inconspicuous and fail to make an aesthetic impact.
- Ceiling Height: Fans should be high enough to avoid accidents but low enough to effectively circulate air. The ideal height from the floor to the fan blades is approximately 8 feet although this can vary significantly if you have very high ceilings. If the ceiling is higher, downrods can be used to lower the fan to an appropriate level.
- Number of Fans: In very large or elongated rooms, it might be more effective to install two smaller fans instead of one large fan.
Ceiling Fan Motor Types Explained
Ceiling fan motors are a crucial component in determining the efficiency and longevity of the fan. There are primarily three types of motors used in ceiling fans: AC motors, DC motors, and EC motors.
For energy efficiency and quiet operation, DC and EC motors are superior, though they come at a higher initial cost. AC motors, while less efficient, are more cost-effective and widely available.
Here’s are the basic pros/cons of each type:
AC Motors (Alternating Current Motors)
Historically, most ceiling fan motors were AC motors. These were standard due to their simplicity, cost-effectiveness, and reliability.
Pros:
- Cost-Effective: Generally, AC motors are less expensive to produce, resulting in more affordable ceiling fans.
- Widespread Availability: AC motor fans are widely available in various designs and styles.
- Speed Variation: If you have a wall switch that controls the fan power, you can use a smart fan controller to adjust the fan speed.
Cons:
- Energy Efficiency: They are less energy-efficient compared to DC and ECM motors.
- Noise Level: Tend to be noisier, especially at higher speeds. If you’ve ever heard a ceiling fan make an annoying wahh-wahh-wahh type humming sound, this is the result of an AC motor that is getting old and worn out.
- Speed Variation: Limited onboard speed options compared to DC motors.
DC Motors (Direct Current Motors)
In the mid-2000s, DC motors in ceiling fans started becoming more popular. This was partly driven by advancements in semiconductor technology, which made it more practical to produce efficient and compact DC motors. Additionally, DC motors are significantly more energy-efficient compared to traditional AC motors, which resonates with the growing demand for eco-friendly and cost-saving home appliances.
Pros:
- Energy Efficiency: DC motors use up to 70% less electricity compared to AC motors.
- Quieter Operation: They operate more quietly, making them ideal for bedrooms and quiet spaces.
- Lightweight: DC motors are lighter, which can simplify installation.
- Speed and Control: Offer a greater number of speed settings and are often paired with remote controls.
Cons:
- Cost: Tend to be more expensive upfront due to the technology and materials used.
- Repair and Maintenance: Repairing a DC motor can be more complicated and expensive. However, most ceiling fans today are sold with a lifetime warranty on the motor.
ECMs (Electronically Commutated Motors)
ECMs represent a significant advancement in motor technology blending features of both AC and DC motors. Big Ass Fans use ECMs in many of their models. This choice aligns with their focus on energy efficiency and high performance.
Pros:
- High Efficiency: ECMs combine the best of AC and DC motors. They are extremely energy-efficient, often exceeding the efficiency of standard DC motors.
- Quiet Operation: Like DC motors, ECMs operate very quietly, making them suitable for noise-sensitive environments.
- Longevity and Reliability: These motors are known for their long service life and reliability.
- Speed Control and Smart Features: Offer precise speed control and are often used in smart, programmable fans.
Cons:
- Cost: ECMs are typically the most expensive type of motor due to their advanced technology.
- Repair and Maintenance Complexity: Similar to DC motors, repairing an ECM can be more complex. But again, you will most likely have a lifetime warranty on the motor.
Ceiling Fan Efficiency – Does it really matter?
I frequently see ceiling fan makers advertise how efficient their motors are. While I’m totally onboard with cutting edge eco-friendly ceiling fan motor technology, my research indicates that the potential for savings is actually quite small. The table below shows some efficiency data for a few modern smart ceiling fan. I chose one of each motor type to illustrate the difference between them.
Hunter Aerodyne | Minka-Aire Sleek | Big Ass Fans Haiku L | |
Motor Type | AC | DC | EC |
Airflow efficiency (CFM/Watt) | 106 | 181 | 256 |
Power usage at top speed (Watts) | 48 | 31 | 20 |
Airflow at top speed (CFM) | 5108 | 5655 | 5204 |
Size (inches) | 52 | 60 | 52 |
While the difference in power usage looks to be quite drastic (the Aerodyne uses nearly 2.5X more power than the Haiku L), the actual power use doesn’t add up to much. If you were to run these fans at maximum speed for an entire year, you would save about $37 (assuming electricity cost of $0.15/kwh) by using the Haiku L over the Aerodyne.
Of course, that’s not nothing. But, who runs their fans at maximum speed 24/7?
Not me.
I think a better estimate would be to run it on low 24/7. Unfortunately I couldn’t find efficiency data for these fans on low speed. I did find data for the Minka-Aire fan and it uses about 1/10th the power on low as it does on high. If I estimate the same for the Aerodyne and Haiku L, then the savings after 1 year of running on low speed would only be $3.70.
That’s pretty much nothing.
To be fair, if your current fan is 40 years old and humming and wobbling to a much needed “retirement” in the county landfill, then a new more efficient ceiling fan could be a big improvement.
But, if your choice is between any one of these new smart ceiling fans, then energy cost savings shouldn’t be much of a consideration.
Final Thoughts
The Minka-Aire fans stand out as the best overall choice, offering a blend of quality, price, and smart home compatibility that will satisfy both novice users and advanced users.
For those who are seeking cutting-edge features and are less price-sensitive, the Big Ass Fans models with SenseMe technology (such as the es6) are the best that money can buy.
Meanwhile, the SMAFAN fans provide excellent value, catering well to budget-conscious consumers, so long as you don’t mind dabbling in the “Smart Life” ecosystem.